Recapping EVERY Trade of the Deadline

Wow, what a whirlwind week of baseball wheelin’ and dealin’ we’ve had. I’m exhausted just from trying to keep track of all the trades that went down in the past week or so. Some teams look completely different (helloooooo, Dodgers) and some we thought would get a face lift, look exactly the same (what’s wrong, Rays?).

But this is your home for all things deadline – where you can get every dirty detail of every trade that went down, plus a quick analysis of the deals. For the sake of brevity, only trades from July 24th through the end of the deadline are included. But, I won’t keep you waiting any longer…let’s get it rolling:

7/24 – Pittsburgh Pirates + Houston Astros

Pittsburgh acquires Wandy Rodriguez (SP)

Houston acquires Rudy Owens (SP), Colton Cain (SP) and Robbie Grossman (OF)

The Pirates’ pitching staff has been stellar all year, but they felt they needed more depth. In Rodriguez, they get a veteran who has been pedestrian at times, brilliant at others, overall one of the better catches on the pitching market. And Houston is on the fast track to 100 losses, so any young talent helps. They snagged three guys who were in the top 20 of the Pirates’ very deep minor league system.

Winner: Pirates

Tampa Bay Rays + Arizona Diamondbacks

Tampa Bay acquires Ryan Roberts (3B)

Arizona acquires Tyler Bortnick (IF)

Roberts, otherwise known as Tatman by his legions of fans in Arizona, was designated for assignment before being traded to the Rays. It gives Tampa a much-needed bat with some pop at a position they don’t necessarily need help at when Evan Longoria is healthy. The D’Backs like what they see with Bortnick, but he was sent to Triple-A, so it clearly wasn’t a move they expected to impact the club in 2012.

Winner: Rays

7/25 – Los Angeles Dodgers + Miami Marlins

Los Angeles acquires Randy Choate (RP) and Hanley Ramirez (3B/SS)

Miami acquires Nathan Eovaldi (SP) and Scott McGough (RP)

The dividends of this trade has already paid off for both squads – the Dodgers swept the rival Giants in San Francisco last weekend, largely in part to Ramirez and his clutch hits. Choate has already come in and fended off opposing lefty hitters in a couple of appearances. And Eovaldi made a good first start in Miami. McGough is a bit of a project but has a high ceiling in Single-A. The Dodgers traded long-term guys for immediate help. Read more about this trade HERE.

Winner: Dodgers

7/27 – Los Angeles Angels + Milwaukee Brewers

Los Angeles acquires Zack Greinke (SP)

Milwaukee acquires Juan Segura (SS), Johnny Hellweg (SP), Ariel Pena (SP)

The Angels bolstered an already-scary rotation with the addition of former Cy Young winner Greinke. He joins Dan Haren, C.J. Wilson and Jered Weaver in Anaheim. The Brewers got quite a haul in return, as all three prospects were top ten in the Angels’ system. Pena’s name stands out because he had a 216.00 ERA in his Futures Game appearance this year. Oops! Just for the sheer ridiculousness of the Angels’ new rotation, they win this trade. Read more about this trade HERE.

Winner: Angels

Colorado Rockies + San Francisco Giants

Colorado acquires Charlie Culberson (2B)

San Francisco acquires Marco Scutaro (IF)

Neither team needed to make this move, but it happened anyway. Scutaro gives the Giants a quality, veteran utility player who will definitely not solve their offensive woes. At best, Scutaro will find random ways to be in the lineup as soon as Pablo Sandoval returns from injury. Culberson is a good prospect and has a shot at stardom if he continues to progress. This one is a toss-up.

Winner: Push

7/29 – Chicago White Sox + Minnesota Twins

Chicago acquires Francisco Liriano (SP)

Minnesota acquires Eduardo Escobar (IF) and Pedro Hernandez (SP)

If the Sox think Liriano will be the added depth they need in the rotation to compete down the stretch, they are sorely mistaken. Brilliant occasionally, awful usually, Liriano was let go by the Twins because they just couldn’t take it anymore. They were able to pry a light-hitting, yet slick-fielding top-10 hitting prospect and a left-handed pitcher from Chicago. But the ultimate victory was ridding themselves of Liriano. Read more about this trade HERE.

Winner: Twins

Arizona Diamondbacks + Houston Astros

Arizona acquires Chris Johnson (3B)

Houston acquires Marc Krauss (1B/OF) and Bobby Borchering (3B/OF)

If you’re Houston…why not? You are selling everyone and their mothers anyway, so if a corner infielder is shipped away, bring in two others who are younger and can be molded however you see fit. Johnson hit a huge grand slam yesterday against the division rival Dodgers, so he’s already a D’Back hero. But this trade didn’t really hurt either team. Again, a default winner.

Winner: Diamondbacks

7/30 – Texas Rangers + Chicago Cubs

Texas acquires Geovany Soto (C) and cash

Chicago acquires Jacob Brigham (SP)

Another NL Central team going full fire sale, the Cubs gladly took the Rangers up on their offer to rid the club of a former Rookie of the Year in Soto, who had steadily declined both in health and production. Brigham is a pitcher the Rangers had pretty high hopes for that just wasn’t panning out. It looks like he’ll have to earn his way to the majors as a relief pitcher now. Texas designated Yorvit Torrealba in response to getting Soto.

Winner: Rangers

Atlanta Braves + Chicago Cubs

Atlanta acquires Reed Johnson (OF), Paul Maholm (SP) and cash

Chicago acquires Arodys Vizcaino (RP) and Jaye Chapman (RP)

The Braves got a veteran utility outfielder and an underrated big league starter for two minor league relievers. Sounds like a pretty sweet deal. That being said, Vizcaino has an exceptionally high ceiling. He was the number two prospect in the Braves organization coming into 2012, but was sidelined and needed Tommy John surgery in March. Not yet 22, we could see the hard-throwing right hander closing out games at Wrigley Field by 2014.

Winner: Braves

Pittsburgh Pirates + Toronto Blue Jays

Pittsburgh acquires Travis Snider (OF) 

Toronto acquires Brad Lincoln (RP)

This was a surprising and somewhat strange trade, but the Pirates got another high-potential bat in Snider, in exchange for a pretty solid reliever in Lincoln. Snider has great power potential but hasn’t put it together yet in the Majors. If he does, the Pirates got a steal. Lincoln is no slouch though. His 2.73 ERA in the Pirates’ bullpen this season opened some eyes, and the Blue Jays intend to let him try his hand as a set up man.

Winner: Push

Seattle Mariners + Toronto Blue Jays

Seattle acquires Eric Thames (OF)

Toronto acquires Steve Delabar (RP)

I actually like what the Blue Jays are doing. They know they have the offense, but need to bolster the pitching staff in the rotation and bullpen. So they are trading high-potential, excess bats to bring in some quality bullpen help. Delabar is a good pick-up, and Thames won’t be missed in that lineup. For the Mariners, who are always looking for bats, they are hoping Thames continues to improve and becomes a legit power threat from the right side of the plate.

Winner: Mariners

Seattle Mariners + Los Angeles Dodgers

Seattle acquires Logan Bawcom (RP) and Leon Landry (OF)

Los Angeles acquires Brandon League (RP)

The only reason the Dodgers made this move was because they were planning to move one of their current right handers in the bullpen, Josh Lindblom. League replaces Lindblom and is a slight upgrade, though it’s not a hugely noteworthy trade overall. The M’s pulled in a pretty good pitching prospect who needs a lot of work and a young, fast outfielder who has put up HUGE numbers at Single-A.

Winner: Mariners

7/31 – Los Angeles Dodgers + Philadelphia Phillies

Los Angeles acquires Shane Victorino (OF)

Philadelphia acquires Josh Lindblom (RP), Ethan Martin (SP) and Player To Be Named Later/Cash

A trade between the two biggest movers netted each team a pretty good haul. The Dodgers were in desperate need of an upgrade in the outfield and at the very top of the lineup, and came away with both in one guy. Philly received a good set up man who can become great with some consistency in Lindblom. But Martin may be a steal, considering the solid year he’s having in Double-A. Read more about this trade HERE.

Winner: Dodgers

San Francisco Giants + Philadelphia Phillies

San Francisco acquires Hunter Pence (OF)

Philadelphia acquires Nate Schierholtz (OF), Tommy Joseph (C), Seth Rosin (SP)

The Giants needed to answer their rivals’ big pick ups of Victorino and Ramirez, so they swung a move for a great all-around player in Pence. They lost a back up outfielder with a great arm in Schierholtz and their number two propsect in Joseph, but the immediate returns should more than make up for it. San Francisco is plenty deep at catcher for the foreseeable future, so Joseph was expendable. Great pick up for the Phils there though. Read more about this trade HERE.

Winner: Giants

Miami Marlins + St. Louis Cardinals

Miami acquires Zack Cox (3B)

St. Louis acquires Edward Mujica (RP)

This trade was completely unnecessary for the Redbirds, as their bullpen had been nearly impenetrable as of late. After slow starts, Mitchell Boggs and Mark Rzepczynski had turned it around and that relief corps was hot. Not that Mujica won’t just bolster it further, but did they really want to give up a top-five offensive prospect for a middle reliever? Miami scores again. Fire sale mode has worked wonders for the disappointing new-look Marlins.

Winner: Marlins

Arizona Diamondacks + Boston Red Sox

Arizona acquires Scott Podsednik (OF) and Matt Albers (RP) 

Boston acquires Craig Breslow (RP)

This isn’t much of a trade, despite all three players being Major League level. The Sox and D’Backs essentially swapped pretty good relievers, though Breslow is a lefty, Albers is not. So the Red Sox get the edge there. And while Arizona doesn’t necessarily need any help in the outfield, Podsednik can get on base and provide some speed. It’s the little things that will allow the D’Backs to climb back into the NL West race here.

Winner: Diamondbacks

Pittsburgh Pirates + Miami Marlins

Pittsburgh acquires Gaby Sanchez (1B) and Kyle Kaminska (RP)

Miami acquires Gorkys Hernandez (OF) and 2013 competitive balance draft pick

The Pirates continue to make under-the-radar moves that should help their playoff push in 2012. Sanchez was replaced by Carlos Lee in Miami, despite being mired in a similar slump as El Caballo. Hernandez goes to the Fish in a trade that really helps both sides. Sanchez has put up big numbers in the Majors in years past, while Hernandez has been a top prospect for Pittsburgh for a few years. Time will tell which team comes out on top.

Winner: Push

Cincinnati Reds + Kansas City Royals

Cincinnati acquires Jonathan Broxton (RP)

Kansas City acquires J.C. Sulbaran (SP) and Donnie Joseph (RP)

I understand that the Reds didn’t want to be left out, but this is an embarrasment of riches. They didn’t need bullpen help. That being said, you can never have enough quality bullpen arms. I also understand that the Royals need pitching, but what if Joakim Soria isn’t back to full strength after he returns next season? They better hope Sulbaran, Joseph and Soria pan out, or they let a good closer walk for cheap.

Winner: Reds

New York Yankees + Pittsburgh Pirates

New York acquires Casey McGehee (1B/3B)

Pittsburgh acquires Chad Qualls (RP)

At the last second, the Yanks just had to do something. Anything. And they actually made a pretty shrewd move, getting someone the Pirates felt they didn’t need, in return for a veteran reliever. Qualls is good, he’s always been steady – but the Yankees might be laughing if McGehee can actually step in and fill the shoes of the crippled Mark Teixeira and Alex Rodriguez for them. Pirates get another bullpen arm, Yankees get a power bat. Close call.

Winner: Yankees

Texas Rangers + Chicago Cubs

Texas acquires Ryan Dempster (SP)

Chicago acquires Christian Villanueva (3B) and Kyle Hendricks (SP)

After weeks of drama, the curtain finally fell on the Cubs’ ace Dempster, who wound up in Texas. It makes you wonder if the Rangers already assumed Neftali Feliz was seriously injured (announced earlier today that he would need season-ending Tommy John surgery) before the trade was made. The Cubs stack the minor league system with two more guys who can be molded into very good players a couple of seasons down the road. Read more about this trade HERE.

Winner: Rangers

Boston Red Sox + Cleveland Indians

Boston acquires Steven Wright (SP)

Cleveland acquires Lars Anderson (1B/OF)

Um. Who? I don’ t know. So I did a little research. The last trade before the deadline hit looks on paper as if it favors the Red Sox. Wright is a 27-year-old knuckleballing reliever who had a pretty nifty ERA in Double-A this season. If he comes around late like R.A. Dickey, who knows? And Anderson was formerly thought to be a top prospect, but has struggled in the minors. At only 24 years old, the Tribe is willing to take their chances.

Winner: Red Sox

There you have it folks. A run down of the last week of trading in Major League Baseball, leading up to the crazy finale of the trade deadline. Are you surprised at some of these trades? Anyone still in the same uniforms who you thought would have been moved?

Let us know in the comments below, or Tweet us @3u3d. You can also LIKE Three Up, Three Down on Facebook!

- Jeremy Dorn (@Jamblinman)

1 Comment

This deal is good in the short term for the Dodgers but I am not convinced it’s a good long term move. Yes, Rameriez is recovering from an injury but he isn’t the player he once was. Just look at his numbers. His 2009 was ridiculous but he has declined every year since then. It’s true that he is recovering from an injury but his career has taken a sharp turn for the worse since 2009. Just look at his WAR since then.

2009: 7.1 WAR
2010: 2.6 WAR
2011: 0.0 WAR
2012: -0.5 WAR (So far, -0.7 WAR with MIA, 0.2 with LAD)

It would appear that so far the change of scenery has really helped him early on but he isn’t the elite level infielder he use to be anymore. He could potentially recover to that but I wouldn’t call this a clear steal. A solid high upside prospect for a guy whose really struggled the last few years and hasn’t been a quality player since 2010. Both Ramirez and Eovaldi are players with high upside but a lot of uncertainty. Given both players have struggled at times but have shown flashes of brilliance I would say its a pretty fair deal. I would give the Dodgers the slight edge in value because Ramirez is proven while Eovaldi is still more of an unknown but remember LA is on the hook for over $30 Million dollars through 2014.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 162 other followers

%d bloggers like this: